Historical Thinking and Other Unnat...
Wishlist
Although most of us think of history--and learn it--as a conglomeration of facts, dates, and key figures, for professional historians it is a way of knowing, a method for developi…
Book Summary
Sam Wineburg's 'Historical Thinking and Other Unnatural Acts' is a landmark exploration of how students actually learn history—and why it defies common sense. Drawing on cognitive research and classroom evidence, Wineburg shows that historical thinking is an unnatural, disciplined practice, not a natural byproduct of reading. This edition remains essential for educators, curriculum designers, and anyone interested in the psychology of learning history.
This book is not available
Store  |
Condition |
Deals & Coupons | Price |
Est. Shipping |
Total |
Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sorry we could not find any result for “9781566398565” | ||||||
About Historical Thinking and Other Unnat...
In 'Historical Thinking and Other Unnatural Acts,' Stanford professor Sam Wineburg challenges the assumption that history is simply a matter of memorizing facts. Through a series of insightful essays, he reveals that historical thinking—sourcing, contextualizing, and corroborating evidence—is an 'unnatural' act that must be explicitly taught. Wineburg contrasts how historians and students read historical documents, showing that expertise involves a set of disciplined habits rather than innate ability. He also examines the role of empathy, the use of textbooks, and the assessment of historical understanding. This book is a foundational text in history education, offering both a theoretical framework and practical implications for teaching. It is particularly valuable for teacher educators and researchers seeking to understand why students struggle with historical reasoning and how instruction can be redesigned to foster genuine historical literacy.
Who should read Historical Thinking and Other Unnat...?
This book is essential reading for pre-service and in-service history teachers, curriculum developers, and teacher educators who want to understand the cognitive challenges of historical thinking. It is also valuable for researchers in history education and cognitive psychology, as well as for advanced undergraduate or graduate students in education. Additionally, anyone interested in how expertise develops and how disciplinary thinking differs from everyday reasoning will find it compelling. School administrators and policymakers involved in history standards and assessment will also benefit from its insights.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- ✓ Groundbreaking research that fundamentally reshapes how educators understand historical thinking.
- ✓ Accessible writing that blends cognitive psychology with vivid classroom examples.
- ✓ Provides a clear framework for teaching historical reasoning rather than mere factual recall.
- ✓ Includes practical implications for curriculum design and assessment.
- ✓ Highly influential and widely cited in the field of history education.
Cons
- ✗ Some essays are dense and assume familiarity with educational research.
- ✗ The focus is primarily on theory and research; practical lesson plans are limited.
- ✗ Examples are drawn largely from U.S. history, which may limit applicability for other contexts.
- ✗ The book is a collection of essays, so some repetition occurs across chapters.
- ✗ Readers seeking a step-by-step teaching manual may find it too abstract.
Similar books
Frequently asked questions
Is this book a practical guide for lesson planning?
Not exactly. While it offers many implications for teaching, it is primarily a research-based exploration of how historical thinking develops. Teachers will need to translate the ideas into their own lesson plans.
What does 'unnatural acts' mean in the title?
Wineburg argues that historical thinking is 'unnatural' because it goes against our everyday ways of reading and understanding the world. It requires deliberate training and discipline, much like other expert practices.
Is this book suitable for elementary teachers?
Yes, though the examples often focus on secondary and college students. The core principles about sourcing and contextualizing apply across grade levels, and elementary teachers can adapt the ideas.
Does the book include empirical research?
Yes. Wineburg draws on his own and others' cognitive studies, including think-aloud protocols and comparisons between historians and students, to build his arguments.
Is this edition different from the original?
This is the 2001 paperback edition. It includes the original essays and a new introduction. There is no substantially revised edition, so it remains the standard version.
At Windsorbooks, we compare prices from trusted sellers so you can buy, rent, or sell textbooks at the best total price — shipping included.
As an Amazon Associate, Windsorbooks.com may earn a small commission on qualifying purchases.